|Randy Shoehand's Voting History|
|Episode|| Randy Shoehand's|
| Voted Against|
|1||Ngaka Tribe Immune|
|3||Puku Tribe Immune|
|4||None1||Penalty2, Billy, Jordan|
|Voted Off, Day 11|
|5||On Redemption Island|
|Eliminated, Day 13|
- 1: Due to the Sacrificial Lamb challenge, Randy elected to have his vote taken away from him.
- 2: Due to the Sacrificial Lamb challenge, Randy elected to have an extra vote cast against him.